• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe

Motion Control Tips

Automation • Motion Control • Power Transmission

  • News
    • Industry News
    • Editor Blogs
  • Controls
    • HMIs
    • PC-Based Controllers
    • PLCs + PACs
    • Stand-Alone Controllers
    • Software
  • Drives
    • Servo Drives
    • Stepper Drives
  • Encoders
    • Absolute Encoders
    • Incremental Encoders
    • Rotary Encoders
  • Mechanical
    • Bearings
    • Brakes + Clutches
    • Belt + chain
    • Couplings
    • Gears + Gearing
    • Lubrication
    • Shock + Vibration Mitigation
    • Springs + Rings + Seals
  • Linear
    • Actuators
    • Linear Motors
    • Linear Encoders
  • Motors
    • AC Motors
    • DC Motors
    • Brushless Motors
    • Gearmotors
    • Piezo Motors
    • Servo Motors
    • Stepper Motors
  • Systems
    • Conveyors + linear transport systems
    • Gantries + Stages
    • Rotary Tables
    • Grippers + End Effectors
    • Robotics
  • Networks
    • Connections + Sliprings
    • Fieldbuses
    • I/O
    • Sensors + Vision
  • Resources
    • FAQs
      • Motion Casebook
      • Motion Selection Guides
    • Suppliers
    • Video
You are here: Home / FAQs + basics / FAQ: How do direct-drive (torque) motors compare to gearmotors?

FAQ: How do direct-drive (torque) motors compare to gearmotors?

March 10, 2017 By Miles Budimir Leave a Comment

Updated May 2019 || Direct-drive motors and gearmotors are often applied to the same types of applications. Both eliminate the need for power-transmission components that unwanted add compliance between the motor and load. This includes components such as belts and pulleys, chains and sprockets, and external gearboxes. Eliminating these mechanical devices (or in the case of gearmotors, integrating the gears for a single motor build) makes for top efficiency.

Gearmotors are typically less expensive than most direct-drive motors. Plus gearmotors offer good reliability and a fairly long useful life, so are applicable to even general-purpose applications.

On the other hand, direct-drive torque motors offer better dynamic performance in terms of higher control-loop bandwidth. Direct-drive motors are relatively costly, though … and so are primarily used in niche applications. But as their cost goes down, direct-drive torque motors will become increasingly competitive with gearmotors.

motors
This direct-drive rotary table from ETEL connects the motor directly to the load, eliminating power-transmission elements for top efficiency.
motors
This is an AKM series washdown gearmotor from Kollmorgen. It’s designed for packing applications.

Application example: Direct-drive torque motors operate in elevators

Elevators from Schindler Elevator Corp. operate in buildings around the world. Motion technology abounds in the elevator shaft, motor chamber, control box, and cab. Now some new installations use direct-drive motors to open and close the doors of the cab and floor being accessed.

Image courtesy Schindler Elevator Corp.

The mechatronic system (called the Door Drive) was developed in partnership with maxon and is based on a flat 90-mm brushless motor and an integrated MILE encoder as well as a customized positioning controller based on maxon’s EPOS2 series. The brushless dc motor system is then encased in a housing for mounting directly to the lift cab.

The mechatronic system (called the Door Drive) was developed in partnership with maxon and is based on a flat 90-mm brushless motor and an integrated MILE encoder as well as a customized positioning controller based on maxon’s EPOS2 series.

The Door Drive comes in a powerful version using a belt drive to move doors to 400 kg. A smaller and newer version is a direct-drive variation to save space in applications with doors to 120 kg. The system is power dense, reliable, and intelligent: Upon installation, the Door Drive accepts calibration to suit the elevator and cab type, local safety standards, and size and weight of the elevator doors. For the latter, the Door Drive autonomously optimizes the controls to simplifies technician work.

The motor’s flatness and compactness allows the cab to be bigger. The direct drive also saves energy and while delivering consistent torque output to smoothly move the doors. The integrated controller includes IIoT functionality — collecting operational data for technicians to access.

You Might Also Like

Filed Under: FAQs + basics Tagged With: Etel Linear Motors, Kollmorgen

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

LEARNING CENTER

Design World Learning Center

Motion Control Handbook

“mct
EXPAND YOUR KNOWLEDGE AND STAY CONNECTED
Get the latest info on technologies, tools and strategies for Design Engineering Professionals.

RSS Featured White Papers

  • Robotic Automation is Indispensable for the Logistics Industry’s Continued Growth and Success
  • Reliable Linear Motion For Packaging Machines
  • Polymers Outperform Metals In Precision Gearing

Footer

Motion Control Tips

DESIGN WORLD NETWORK

Design World Online
The Robot Report
Coupling Tips
Linear Motion Tips
Bearing Tips
Fastener Engineering.
Wire and Cable Tips

MOTION CONTROL TIPS

Subscribe to our newsletter
Advertise with us
Contact us
About us

Copyright © 2025 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Privacy Policy | RSS