• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Motion Control Tips

Automation • Motion Control • Power Transmission

  • News
    • Industry News
    • Editor Blogs
    • Video
  • Controls
    • HMIs
    • PC-Based Controllers
    • PLCs + PACs
    • Stand-Alone Controllers
    • Software
  • Drives
    • Servo Drives
    • Stepper Drives
  • Encoders
    • Absolute Encoders
    • Incremental Encoders
    • Rotary Encoders
  • Mechanical
    • Bearings
    • Brakes + Clutches
    • Belt + chain
    • Couplings
    • Gears + Gearing
    • Lubrication
    • Shock + Vibration Mitigation
    • Springs + Rings + Seals
  • Linear
    • Actuators
    • Linear Motors
    • Linear Encoders
  • Motors
    • AC Motors
    • DC Motors
    • Brushless Motors
    • Gearmotors
    • Piezo Motors
    • Servo Motors
    • Stepper Motors
  • Systems
    • Conveyors + linear transport systems
    • Gantries + Stages
    • Rotary Tables
    • Grippers + End Effectors
    • Robotics
  • Networks
    • Connections + Sliprings
    • Fieldbuses
    • I/O
    • Sensors + Vision
  • FAQs
    • Motion Casebook
    • Motion Selection Guides
  • Suppliers
You are here: Home / FAQs + basics / How do manufacturers address cogging in linear motors?

How do manufacturers address cogging in linear motors?

November 6, 2021 By Danielle Collins Leave a Comment

Iron core linear motors are known for their high continuous and peak force capabilities, good thermal management, and excellent force-to-size ratio. But they’re also known to produce cogging forces, which lead to force ripple, or variation in output force. But how much of a problem is cogging for iron core linear motors, and what are manufacturers doing to address it?


iron core motor
Force is the product of the current in the windings and the magnetic flux density.
Image credit: Rockwell Automation

Cogging force is a result of the magnetic attraction between the “teeth,” or protrusions, of the iron lamination stack (the primary part, or forcer) and the permanent magnets of the magnet track (the secondary part). The product of the magnetic flux density and the current in the coils produces a horizontal force that propels the primary along the track.

But as the primary moves across the secondary, the individual teeth of the primary experience a fluctuating level of magnetic attraction to the magnets, meaning that the horizontal force also fluctuates. So at some positions, very little force is required to move the primary, and at other positions, more force is needed to overcome the magnetic attraction between primary and secondary. This fluctuation in the amount of force required to keep the primary moving at constant velocity is referred to as cogging force.

iron core linear motor
Iron “teeth” in the primary, or forcer, create a strong magnetic attraction with the permanent magnets of the secondary.
Image credit: Chieftek Precision

For point-to-point applications, some amount of cogging force, or force ripple, can be tolerated, since the application’s main concern is reaching the target position, and smoothness of motion isn’t critical. But for applications such as scanning and metrology, where smoothness of motion is paramount, cogging must be kept to a minimum.

Although the only way to eliminate cogging is to eliminate the attractive forces between the primary and the secondary — which is exactly what an ironless linear motor does, by embedding the windings of the primary in epoxy — manufacturers have developed solutions to significantly reduce cogging forces in iron core linear motors, making them suitable even for applications that are highly sensitive to force ripple.


cogging in linear motors
To reduce cogging in iron core linear motors, some manufacturers skew the magnets, as shown here, to reduce the sharp change in attractive forces as the primary moves across the magnets.
Image credit: Aerotech

The first method to reduce cogging in an iron core linear motor is to alter the sharp transitions in attractive forces as the primary (lamination stack) moves over the secondary (magnet track). This done by skewing the positions of the magnets or of the laminations (although skewing the magnets is more common), or by using magnets with a special shape, such as an elongated octagon.

Both methods create an overlap of the magnetic fields of adjacent magnets. So rather than sharp transitions between the magnets (and, therefore, the magnetic attraction), there is a more gradual change in the magnetic attraction as the primary moves across the magnet track. While magnet skewing and shaping are the most common methods for reducing cogging forces, they also reduce the motor’s torque-producing capability and efficiency, since the alignment of the magnetic fields in these designs is not optimal.

Another approach uses destructive interference to cancel out the cogging forces. In this method, the primary contains more lamination teeth than there are magnets on the secondary (magnet track) – a winding method known as fractional winding. This imbalance between the number of teeth in the primary and magnets on the secondary allows the cogging forces caused by the inner teeth to cancel out.

The cogging force created by the outer teeth is addressed by adding a triangle to each end of the lamination stack, changing its shape from a rectangle to a parallelogram. These triangles on the ends of the lamination stack are shifted by 180 degrees in the magnetic cycle and create cogging forces equal but opposite to those created by the the outer teeth of the lamination stack. This, in combination with the fractional winding, virtually eliminates force ripple.

cogging in linear motors
The triangular sections at each end of this lamination stack create cogging forces equal but opposite to those of the lamination stack, creating destructive interference that virtually eliminates the total cogging forces.
Image credit: Parker Hannifin

In addition to hardware solutions, which involve added cost and manufacturing complexity, cogging can also be addressed in the servo control system. Specifically, a feed-forward signal to the current command will smooth the motor’s force production and torque ripple. And keep in mind that torque ripple also causes velocity ripple, so a high-bandwidth velocity control loop, together with feed-forward commands, can help to smooth velocity for applications that are highly sensitive to speed fluctuations.

cogging in linear motors
Advanced servo algorithms can recognize and compensate for cogging in iron core motors.
Image credit: ACS Motion Control

Feature image credit: Nippon Pulse

linear motor

You may also like:

  • direct drive
    What is a direct drive in the context of motion…
  • eddy currents
    What are eddy currents and how do they affect motor…
  • tubular linear motors
    When do tubular linear motors outperform traditional iron core and…
  • linear motor
    3 things to consider when choosing a linear servo motor
  • Halbach array
    What is a Halbach array and how is it used…

Filed Under: FAQs + basics, Featured, Motors, Servo Motors

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

POWER TRANSMISSION REFERENCE GUIDE

DESIGN GUIDE LIBRARY

“motion
Subscribe Today

RSS Featured White Papers

  • Specifying electric rodless actuators: Ten tips for maximizing actuator life and system performance
  • The truth about actuator life: Screw drive survival
  • Top Ten Tips: How to specify electric rod-style actuators for optimal performance, reliability and efficiency

Footer

Motion Control Tips

DESIGN WORLD NETWORK

Design World Online
The Robot Report
Coupling Tips
Linear Motion Tips
Bearing Tips
Fastener Engineering.

MOTION CONTROL TIPS

Subscribe to our newsletter
Advertise with us
Contact us
About us
Follow us on TwitterAdd us on FacebookAdd us on LinkedInAdd us on YouTubeAdd us on Instagram

Copyright © 2022 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Privacy Policy | RSS